Will a filly ever win the Triple Crown? Rachel Alexandra and Ruffian couldn't, but Genuine Risk gave it a good run

Will a filly ever win the Triple Crown? Rachel Alexandra and Ruffian couldn't, but Genuine Risk gave it a good run

With 2009 coming to a close, I started thinking about fillies in Triple Crown races. Winning the Triple Crown is, as most of us know, the toughest accomplishment in all of thoroughbred racing. There have only been 11 horses that have done in, and the last one to do it (Affirmed) was way back in 1978. All of the Triple Crown winners have been colts, so as tough as it is for a male to do it, it's even tougher for a filly. Why? Well, first of all 3-year-old fillies are not as physically developed as their male counterparts, and most of them are just not up to competing over a classic distance against quality colts three times in five weeks. It's extremely rare to see a filly compete in all three Triple Crown races, which underscores my previous point. There are a few examples of fillies winning a Triple Crown race: Winning Colors in the 1988 Kentucky Derby is a good one that comes to mind. You no doubt can remember that in 2007 the fantastic filly Rags to Riches beat Horse of the Year Curlin in a stirring stretch drive to become the first filly in over a century to win the third and toughest leg of the Triple Crown. Some of the very best fillies didn't even compete in the Triple Crown race, like Hall-of-Famers Ruffian, Personal Ensign, and Go for Wand. It is worth mentioning that Curlin, Rags to Riches' adversary in that 2007 Belmont, ran in the Kentucky Derby (finishing third) and won the Preakness Stakes in an awesome battle with Street Sense, the horse that had won the Kentucky Derby just two weeks prior, while Rags to Riches did not run in either race. One can only wonder what would have happened in that 2007 Belmont had Rags to Riches had to compete in the Kentucky Derby and the Preakness before having to go the mile and a half in the Belmont Stakes. Would she have fared as well, worse, better, or the same? Perhaps one day history will look back on 2009 as a missed opportunity for history to be made since the greatest filly in at least a generation, Rachel Alexandra, wasn't entered in the Kentucky Derby. She dominated the Kentucky Oaks and then won the Preakness, so it really wouldn't have made sense to risk running her in the Belmont. However, it sure seems like Rachel Alexandra was that rare 3-year-old filly that had the stuff to not only compete in, but win the Triple Crown. The fact is, we'll never know. One thing we do know is that Genuine Risk is a filly that actually did run in all three Triple Crown races. Not only that, but she also won the Kentucky Derby, finished second in the Preakness and, as you'll see here, capped off a remarkable run by also finishing second in the Belmont. In fact, there are many die-hard fans who, to this day, believe that Angel Cordero, the jockey aboard eventual Preakness winner Codex, fouled the great filly by actually hitting her with his whip while the two horses were coming out of the final turn at Pimlico in 1980, and argue that she should have been declared the winner of the Preakness by the disqualification of Codex. But the fact is, you can't change the past; you can't rewind the clock of time because it marches on. No, Genuine Risk is not as fondly remembered as the previously mentioned superstars or even Lady's Secret, and maybe she wasn't as good, who knows? But by finishing first, second, and then second again in the Triple Crown races, she did something no other filly has ever done, and that's why we at Horse Race Game have a special place in our heart for this genuine equine champion. Even though she passed on in recent years, she will never be forgotten. You can ride Genuine Risk (she will drive like a new sports car) in our fantastic online racing game, and in doing so maybe you can win her the Preakness and Belmont! If you're going to ride her you might want to also bet her in our game and try to cash a big winning ticket. Double your fun and action in our skill game. Please check out all the great horse we have in our store for you to ride, bet and win.



Comments Legend

The headings of our comments provide additional information about the user that made the comment. The legend below explains the different colored headings you will find while reading the comments.

  • The Author
  • VIPs
  • Moderators & Staff
  • Others
  • You can join the conversation by creating your free account. It only takes a few seconds.

richardmacias's picture

Maybe Rachel can do it as a 4 year old

She would be as developed as the colts she will face and she has shown she can beat them. She would make history and could then cap it off with a BCC win and HOY. It would bring such great excitement to the sport.

winmoney's picture

The only problem with that

The only problem with that is that only 3-year-olds are eligible to compete in Triple Crown races, though she sure could win 2010 HOY, no doubt.

richardmacias's picture

Open up the sport

Maybe some tracks can get together and put up a Triple Crown Tournament for thoroughbread four year olds and up of their own and put a new and exciting twist in the sport giving some horses a second chance at greatness.

mangani's picture

Filly Triple Crown

As I am sure you know, there once was a filly Triple Crown (I believe they called it the Triple Tiara) and Ruffian did win it. I don't think they even emphasize it any more -- too bad. A lot of good fillies did win it, too. There even used to be the Handicap Triple Crown -- Whisk Broom II and Kelso won it, and one other horse -- but I think that has been played down over the past few years. I just remembered the other horse -- Fit To Fight.


You may login with either your assigned username or your e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.
  • OldFarleyFan earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • gerimack earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • gerimack earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • OldFarleyFan earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • gerimack earned 500,000 Points playing our game.
  • loveagame earned 474,045 Points playing our game.
  • jaycat earned 426,426 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 415,272 Points playing our game.
  • jerrygates earned 400,000 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 395,109 Points playing our game.
  • kinglilman earned 383,526 Points playing our game.
  • yowdvm earned 368,082 Points playing our game.
  • captainmorgan earned 362,505 Points playing our game.
  • ronron900 earned 361,389 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 332,046 Points playing our game.
  • jaycat earned 313,813 Points playing our game.
  • nickvegas earned 310,510 Points playing our game.
  • kinglilman earned 305,019 Points playing our game.
  • loveagame earned 300,300 Points playing our game.
  • mattaliendi66@gmail.com earned 300,000 Points playing our game.
  • cavetroll earned 300,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 289,746 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 276,276 Points playing our game.
  • jackpotrace earned 275,117 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 259,116 Points playing our game.
  • pack1998 earned 250,000 Points playing our game.
  • cavetroll earned 250,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 242,084 Points playing our game.
  • loveagame earned 235,950 Points playing our game.
  • kinglilman earned 231,231 Points playing our game.
  • rero0517 earned 229,086 Points playing our game.
  • rlparlett earned 228,800 Points playing our game.
  • Vicodo earned 227,799 Points playing our game.
  • jaw1755 earned 220,720 Points playing our game.
  • oparada earned 217,074 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 215,475 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 212,784 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 209,196 Points playing our game.
  • sleepers earned 203,989 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 202,702 Points playing our game.
  • ahijah earned 202,702 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 202,059 Points playing our game.
  • gerimack earned 201,201 Points playing our game.
  • socalfan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • mattaliendi66@gmail.com earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • OldFarleyFan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • saratoga95 earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • socalfan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • OldFarleyFan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • SilverDollarkid earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • OldFarleyFan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • saratoga95 earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • socalfan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • kingo101 earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • blackcaviar007 earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • saratoga95 earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • socalfan earned 200,000 Points playing our game.
  • sleepers earned 195,624 Points playing our game.
  • sleepers earned 194,766 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 193,830 Points playing our game.
  • schipgal earned 190,476 Points playing our game.
  • lynchd75 earned 188,760 Points playing our game.
  • ahijah earned 187,902 Points playing our game.
  • cavetroll earned 186,186 Points playing our game.
  • ratelic earned 183,826 Points playing our game.
  • jaycat earned 180,823 Points playing our game.
  • romrex666 earned 180,000 Points playing our game.
  • califokie earned 179,595 Points playing our game.
  • realbadwolf earned 179,107 Points playing our game.
  • kinglilman earned 178,464 Points playing our game.
  • jerrygates earned 175,546 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 174,174 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 170,398 Points playing our game.
  • califokie earned 167,310 Points playing our game.
  • buzzomatic69 earned 165,594 Points playing our game.
  • blackghost earned 164,775 Points playing our game.
  • dave69 earned 164,736 Points playing our game.
  • bobbow53 earned 160,512 Points playing our game.
  • shelbyjoe earned 157,014 Points playing our game.
  • ziggyredlag earned 154,440 Points playing our game.
  • dave69 earned 152,700 Points playing our game.
  • ahijah earned 136,890 Points playing our game.
  • quillasbid earned 121,600 Points playing our game.
  • bobbow53 earned 121,600 Points playing our game.
  • kingo101 earned 100,000 Points playing our game.
  • frelance earned 90,000 Points playing our game.
  • frelance earned 90,000 Points playing our game.
  • florida joe earned 82,192 Points playing our game.
  • icemanfirst earned 80,308 Points playing our game.
  • micmac earned 70,999 Points playing our game.
  • kinglilman earned 65,707 Points playing our game.
  • modgraphix earned 53,539 Points playing our game.
  • frelance earned 50,000 Points playing our game.
  • califokie earned 50,000 Points playing our game.
  • califokie earned 50,000 Points playing our game.